As the House decides what to do next with the impeachment inquiry, Ali Velshi and Stephanie Ruhle are joined by Politico’s Anna Palmer, NBC’s Jonathan Allen, and NBC’s Heidi Przybyla to break down what we can expect from lawmakers, Alexander Vindman’s testimony, and the ABC’s of impeachment. Aired on 10/30/19.
» Subscribe to MSNBC:
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, Meet the Press Daily, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House with Nicolle Wallace, Hardball, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and more.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com:
Subscribe to MSNBC Newsletter:
Find MSNBC on Facebook:
Follow MSNBC on Twitter:
Follow MSNBC on Instagram:
More Depositions On Deck As Democrats Push Forward With Impeachment | Velshi & Ruhle | MSNBC
Go patriots ! Get that draft dodger who REFUSED to serve his country out of here.
This is fake news… Everyone saw the playbook the Democrats wrote in 2016.
1) Focus on impeaching Trump
2) File Continuous Lawsuits against Trump
3) Use the internet to delegitimize Trump -Fake news
4) Partner with Facebook to fight ” fake news”
5) Resist the normalization of Trump as President
6) Non- Stop Coverage of Putin
7) Keep repeating Trump lost the popular vote and say he is the least popular president in history
8) Keep saying Trump is a “loser” and tie him to white nationalism
9) Keep positive media coverage of Democrats who call out Trump
This was from the site Democracy Matters which have since removed their pdf from online. But we all remember what the conservatives said about it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqgPyifXG40
@Barry Cochrane and some one tell the guy to stop tweeting. Even worse when admission is in writing hahaha
@Gisele P Why Can’t Trumpists read some of these stories and realize what thing we have as president becausse of their idioticy !
He is more Patriotic than ANY of you Constitution hating, left wing, fuc&tards…
Comma for comma. Yeah right. This man lies every moment
@ohio skane – 💯.
#45’s *cheated and lied to* his partners, both in business *and* marriage, for decades.
He even *cheats* at golf, the ‘gentlemans game’. ⛳
#45 – *So* embarrassing for America… 😒
Toxic Traitor Trump: “This … is a complete transcript of … breaking the law! See, it’s all there, word-for-word….perfect!”
coma for coma, crime for crime, cover up for cover up.
@Tim Countis Correct! Also, cult for cult, con for con, convolution after convolution, crackpot conspiracy after crackpot concpiracy, the GOP is alone, in a league all its own!
The only Deep State that seems to exist is the Republican-Trump desire to run America… even if it means unfair elections, breaking their oath of office, and destroying the Constitution to do it.
@Rod Allen I have educated myself… which is why that link isn’t something I will click on… I have no desire to go to someplace that distorts the facts, or believes that lies are truth. Trump is a liar… he lies about everything. It’s compulsive… He has to lie… He also seems to think that if he lies often enough… that his lies will become truth… Nope. A lie is a lie and he’s the only one to love them. He loves them because if he didn’t… he would have to face the fact that he’s a spoiled rich kid who has no friends and has to pay hookers to even pretend to love him. I know he’s married… he paid good money for her and is getting another kid to turn into a second hand reflection of himself. Trump is a pathetic fat man with no heart.
@RedroomStudios It’s the common practice of compulsive liars that they accuse everyone else of doing what they do. They want to confuse… confusion hides the lies so those who actually believe in the truth will not know what is truth. The big lie here is that Trump actually cares about MAGA… the one thing to think about here is the idea that you have to first tear America down… in order to make it great again. Trump is doing whatever he can to tear America down. And… lying about it all the way to his personal piggy bank. Oh, and helping his Russian backers.
I’ve read the transcripts. Have You? I understood it all. I now see nothing like I have been told. I suggest You read it. This is not worth the time of day people. There is no there there. Right after the “Ya, but do me a favor” I heard about – they talk about 2016 and crowdstrike – there’s nothing about Biden until way later in the conversation that had changed subjects twice in the meantime. It’s plainly obvious that the Dems are just picking a phrase or two from Trump – not telling us the context AGAIN and the trying to convince the mindless of a narrative that is not real ….again. What a crock this is. And You Mistair Arts need to open the other eye.
@olobar5 The Transcript? You mean Trumps memo? I didn’t know they released an actual transcript. All I’ve seen is a memo that says at the bottom that it isn’t a transcript… a memo that has a lot of gaps in it. Frankly, I don’t trust Trump. He lies about everything way to often. You can be his best bud if you want, but I wouldn’t let him in the door…
@CynAnne1 I was looking at that myself , I don’t know what he thought it said. It’s said that most people only read the first paragraph if that.
Get this clown out of there.
@Butter Johnson – Oh, *those* most-unflattering tomes *are already* being written… 📚
https://theweek.com/articles/779929/donald-trump-indisputably-worst-president-american-history
#45 – *So* embarrassing for America.👎
I know right? China doesnt understand your dads costume
I’ve read the transcripts. Have You? I understood it all. I now see nothing like I have been told. I suggest You read it. This is not worth the time of day people. There is no there there. Right after the “Ya, but do me a favor” I heard about – they talk about 2016 and crowdstrike – there’s nothing about Biden until way later in the conversation that had changed subjects twice in the meantime. It’s plainly obvious that the Dems are just picking a phrase or two from Trump – not telling us the context AGAIN and the trying to convince the mindless of a narrative that is not real ….again. What a crock this is.
Butter Johnson asap
@olobar5 Type untruths. Copy. Paste. Paste. Is that you Matt Gaetz?
Trump values personal loyalty more than he values the Truth or the Constitution.
It is a one way loyalty!
Mistair Arts Yeah, he wants everyone loyal to him…. but he’s loyal to none of them.
He has balls,the 44 had no balls
Terry Smithson You’re a little off subject. And more than a little foolish…..
@McKittrick Hyatt – #45 has been exposed… 📖
#KingAhabAndQueenJezebel
13,458 lies so far and they have the nerve to call anyone else a lier
@John Winslow – “Schrodinger’s #45: Criminal *and* cretinous, simultaneously”… 😹
@Real American inbreeding and lead water pipes explains why most Americans are morons.
The political parties remind me of big Time wrestling in the mid-90s the bad guys becoming the good guys and the good guys become the bad guys. It’s a attempt to make us forget that both parties are laiars
@Marvin Guigar you’re being ridiculous Republicans lie to you can’t say one person lies because of the political party that they belong to.Everybody could lie nobody is above lying if they’re human beings.
@Marvin Guigar
Trump: “Believe me, it’s true”
Anyone: “what’s true?”
Trump: “why do you hate me?”
Lock up the orange draft dodger!
Bro trump served in ww2 and 1 as well as the Vietnam war what are you saying. Look up the information on google before you say something so ignorant
groovy_waterbed asap
This is fake news… Everyone saw the playbook the Democrats wrote in 2016.
1) Focus on impeaching Trump
2) File Continuous Lawsuits against Trump
3) Use the internet to delegitimize Trump -Fake news
4) Partner with Facebook to fight ” fake news”
5) Resist the normalization of Trump as President
6) Non- Stop Coverage of Putin
7) Keep repeating Trump lost the popular vote and say he is the least popular president in history
8) Keep saying Trump is a “loser” and tie him to white nationalism
9) Keep positive media coverage of Democrats who call out Trump
This was from the site Democracy Matters which have since removed their pdf from online. But we all remember what the conservatives said about it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqgPyifXG40
She wouldn’t, Christopher. You must be extremely dense if that’s what you were looking for.
President Trump has been corrupt his all life..but now as president is taking it to another level..
Chris H Trump’s attempt to become a dictator is abolishing freedom, using the DOJ to manufacture crimes is a part of what dictators do. You’re lack of knowledge would be amazing, but as you only quote Trump the liar, its not surprising. The DOJ is the very pinnacle of dictatorship corruption happening in full view. Thankfully there seems enough American patriots willing to speak out against anti Americans like you.
@Willie Speirs – May #45 ‘end’ as…’finally’ as ol’ Benito did.
And “Melanie” should make a ‘hasty exit’, asap… 💨👋😏
@Katherine M. yes as I told Chris H he only believes what Trump says. Trump makes things glossed over to suit himself. People died in Ukraine from this neNness. Not cool!
@Chris H you delusional fool
wow, must have been exhausting to research this statement???
Trump is a lowlife who pulls those around him down to his sewer rat level.
@Crystal Giddens 👆👆trump
#ImpeachmentFor45
#tRumpForPrison2020
💸👋😏👎💸
@K H you should be ashamed for attacking The President of the United States!
*Under Proposed ‘Impeachment Inquiry’ Rules, Republicans Can’t Subpoena Whistleblower* they have already started attempting to stack the deck! sick pups!
Impeach “Capital One” Ad and Trumpy Dumpy
Cornelius Gal tell that to the people who sued him for $25 million scamming them in a fake University scheme… Don’t be so gullible you look pathetic.
@Jeffery Graves – ‘Too late’ for Corny… 🤣
@Cornelius Gal Please seek professional help for your obvious delusional issues. It’s never too late, but the earlier you address these problems, the greater likelihood of success, there is.
@Cornelius Gal In fact, you’re comments are so silly, that I don’t think they can be sincere. Citing the White House website as a credible source of Trump’s accomplishments… who would be so stupid?
You’re a comedian, aren’t you? And this is some sort ironic skit on the gullibility of Trumpists, isn’t it?
Trump isn’t even trying to think about a defense that will stand up to future testimony.All He can do is call people names.
@Jean Roch “Never Trumper” will soon be seen as a badge of honor. It’ll probably be a new military medal. Bright orange face with an X though it. 😉
@Jean Roch too true
@Cocoa Liveson too true.
“In the beginning of a change, the patriot is a scarce man, and brave, and hated and scorned. When his cause succeeds, the timid join him, for then it costs nothing to be a patriot.”
Mark Twain
Donna S .. So, you’d rather believe in an old slobbering man, that doesn’t even comb his hair, and who lived with his elderly parent’s until into his 40’s., until he was able to talk idiotic people into voting for him so he could latch on to the tax payer dime support his lazy azz?? You know he was living in his car when he was first elected, because he didn’t want to “WORK”!! Never held a real job his entire life, but he can talk you baby-commies into this TRASH.. to give away your RIGHTS.. to want to live in a communist country, where everything is supposedly FREE, like you’re not going to end up paying for it?? lol Are you ‘right in the head?’ You will OWN NOTHING!! No home, no cars, no savings, no assets – – – EVERYTHING WILL BE CONTROLLED, your money, where you work, for how long you must work, your rent, etc., etc. .. is that what you really want??
A Foggy Frog .. You guys are either on some heavy drugs to believe that garbage or just sick in the head!!
Yes, he is – for the better!!
Hillary Clinton is a patriot. She warned everyone since day one. donnie trump called out, “Russia, if you’re listening…..”
@CynAnne1 ******
I know. And we wouldn’t even have that footage of Trump and the Russians in the oval office if the Russians hadn’t released it. He admits to getting rid of Comey because of the “Russian” thing. Republicans should teach advanced courses in denial. Sometimes I wonder, are all these men (and the occasional woman) that stupid; if not, why are they choosing party and Trump over country? Is it money?
“The A B C’s of impeachment”. Notice how they have to explain impeachment to republicans like an episode of Sesame Street so they can understand?
@Christopher Long Trump and Obama should both face prosecution for war crimes. Too bad liberals don’t care about that anymore.
Criminal defense attorney Fred Flinstone is gonna wanta jump in the pic. Sorry “Atorney General”
Starting to look like frogy but orange
@Chris H – *troll self identifies*
Trump’s his own defense… me, myself and I…
Trump’s ego demands everything be about him. It’s a mental illness and Trump is getting worse as the pressure of impeachment gets greater. Eventually, Trump will burst like a butt boil spewing all sorts of lies in an unhinged White House lawn press conference with the helicopter motors barely heard about Trump’s shouting.
@John Swofford let’s hope so 🙏
@John Swofford he’s gonna burst and die like a coward like his buddy from ISIS
@Rafael Duran – “They pulled #45 from the WH crying, screaming and whimpering…he cowered like a dog…everyone should see this!”
Trump is a drowning man , he is up to his neck now .
then why on earth are republicans sticking their necks out so far for such an obvious loser?? The ship is underwater. Republican congressmen and senators in chorus: ” no it’s not!”
@Rod Allen oh good luck with that Little slice of comfort pie. The impeachment will never remove him because of party over people banana Republicans, but his re-election. Dubious. He may not even qualify to run again with convicted high crimes on his record. You gonna vote for a convicted traitor? Says something about his followers. The Trump Christ has led you astray sir. Come back. It’s ok. Forgiveness is available.
‘TDS’…
‘Trump’s Damnable Schemes’.
Too bad *everyone’s* ‘onto him’ now.
*Every* state, *every* bank, *every* insurance company and *every* country that #45’s *lied to* in his filings *ARE* ‘comparing notes’…and *finding* ‘faults’.
And *soon* #45’s life becomes…a *neverending nightmare* of litigations and losses. 💸📑👋
Yes and Nancy is going to submerge him.
WE do not need a reckless president who believes he is above the law. Lock him up, lock him up. Yeah, that’s right – LOCK HIM UP.
Jason Milton … You won’t be very proud when you are force to READ to your Grandchildren, and Great Grandchildren that your communistic choice turned their lives into miserable slavery, having to work and own nothing – being forced to give it all away to the Government – NO HOME OWNERSHIP – NO CAR – NO LAND, NO MINERALS! *ALL OWNED AND CONTROLLED BY THE GOVERNMENT, NOT THE PEOPLE!! Be sure to copy, paste and print out this INSANE DECISION OF YOURS and place it with all of your important papers i.e. deed to home, car titles, IRA’s, other investment’s that you’ve been afforded t/o your lifetime, so your future generations can see and compare what you had – to what they don’t, because ‘YOU’ gave the freedoms you once enjoyed – away!! And, DON’T BLAME THEM for hating you and that ole’ lazy commie, that never worked a single day in his life – who talked you into this .. you lazy, worthless, crazy old man, you!! DON’T FORGET TO “SAVE THIS,” for the generations who come after you..
GOOD!!
CynAnne1 … ‘YOU’ will commie!!
Oh, Lightn’bug… 🙄
Your ‘EZ Russian 2 English’ app *needs* an update, apparently.
📱👋🤣
Trump’s going to need some Johnson & Johnson.
Or more vaseline
This wh needs an enema on all levels…
an enema, with a big hose, and acid, fluoric acid.
Drain the swamp more like..
flush it down…
The Out House is backed up!
*Remember when “The Chosen One” lied in Aug saying the dollar was at it’s strongest ever?*
Yes I do,meanwhile back in the real world,3 more GM plants are closing,thank the chosen one…
We need 100s of hours and a team of people to remember all his lies.
“Comma for comma” Because everyone knows where the commas go in a phone call!
I know eh? ridiculous!
Jon Krueger Great point!
You don’t talk like that interrogation mark We all talk like that comma why would you doubt that interrogation mark